The Flaming Vegan

A Vegan and Vegetarian Blogging Extravaganza

Don't Buy the Lie! Betta Fish Do Not Live In Mud Puddles!
Facebook Tweet Google+ Pinterest Email More Sharing Options

Don't Buy the Lie! Betta Fish Do Not Live In Mud Puddles!

We've all seen 'em, those colorful fish in tiny cups all lined up on the pet store shelves. The containers look like little clear cups with lids -- there's a reason for that -- supporting a life form. The Betta fish (Betta splendens) inside floats languidly or swims about in a futile effort to find a way out. The cups are easily accessible for kids to play with. Toddlers who escape their mother's grasp momentarily then drop the cups on the floor; teenagers who shake the cups for fun and the overly curious who peek inside for a better look and in so doing scare the daylights out of the fish; are all real dangers to these little guys.

We've all asked 'em, the pet store staff who assure us these fish like living in little cups. Out of concern for their well-being, we ask a pet store clerk why the small cups, and are told time and again some version of the following: they live in mud puddles; they live in the puddled water inside hoof prints of water buffaloes in Asia; they like living in tiny areas; they don't swim much so it's better for them to be in a confined space; they will kill any other fish they come in contact with so they have to be isolated.

Don't buy the lie.

A few years ago I sued the City of West Palm Beach for not allowing protesters to tell the truth about the origins of puppies in pet stores and I asked you not to buy the lie that the puppies all come from "reputable breeders."

Now I am asking again, don't buy the lie about these fish either. I admit it. I gave in to my sympathetic impulses and bought one. I shouldn't have done it because all I did was create a market for them. But I felt so sorry for them that I decided to liberate one of them. The lucky guy, a blue double-tail I call Fuego (blue=sapphire=fire=fuego), has been with me for about a year now; the king of his own five gallon tank. But lately, he's not been feeling too well. I returned from a ten day absence to find him listless and lying on his side. Panicked, I ran to the computer to find out what I could do for him. In researching his condition I have learned quite a bit about these fascinating fish that made me so angry about how the pet stores are deceiving us, that I started an online petition to get the big three pet stores (Petland, Petco and Pet Supermarket) to stop buying them from suppliers who insist on shipping and housing them in those tiny cups.

For example, I learned that many of them die in those little cups from lack of oxygen, diseases brought on by elevated nitrates in the water from their own waste, depression and stress. And although they have been seen in puddles, the truth is they live in shallow streams, ponds and rice paddies in Asia where the water is kept at a warm 75 degrees and oxygen is plentiful. If they are in puddles, it's not by choice, it's because the pond they were in evaporated and they are waiting for rain so they can move on.

A while back there was a craze involving Betta fish where they were being sold in water vases with a plant on top. The idea was the Betta would eat the roots of the plant and survive with little or no work on the part of the owner. Thankfully, it was a passing fad but millions of those little guys died because Betta are omnivores who eat mostly insects and insect larvae in the wild. So while they may eat the roots of a plant to survive (what choice did they have?), they won't thrive because it doesn't provide them the nutrients they need. Also, Betta fish are labyrinth fishes, which mean they take their oxygen from the surface of the water, not the water itself. Since they were unable to get to the surface because the plant was in the way, they couldn't get the oxygen they needed. Finally, Betta fish need to be kept in a pristine environment. Betta experts recommend a 20% water change every week. Those vases did not lend themselves to that because again, the plant was in the way. All of the misinformation about the fish allayed the concerns voiced by those who didn't think it was such a good idea.

But the myths continue, Bettas are not happy and healthy in those little cups. Intelligent, comical and social, these fish become depressed if not stimulated, and will die of starvation because they don't eat when they are depressed. Not only that, female Bettas can be kept together, and male Bettas can be kept in community tanks as long as there are no other male Bettas in them. So all of the reasons we are told about why they are kept in those tiny cups are just, well, lies.

I can attest to the fact that these fish are funny little creatures. Fuego certainly is a character. He sleeps on his side on a leaf or rock at night. He "plays dead" when he thinks I am not paying enough attention to him. He actually floats on his side and when I check on him to see if he's dead, he makes a mad dash around the tank as if to say, "Gotcha again!"

People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals requests we don’t buy these fish. I won’t go that far. I am saying don't buy the lie. I am happy to have saved at least one fish from the misery of a lonely life in the pet store. But if we get our act together enough to speak as one voice and ask the pet stores to stop getting them from suppliers who keep them in tiny cups for the convenience of the pet store, maybe we can help them to have better Betta lives.

To sign the petition, visit

Image credit: Tobias Akerboom (at hutmeelz)

Healthy Snacks Delivered Monthly

+ Add to My Bloggers

Michelle A. Rivera is the author of several books including HOSPICE HOUNDS, Animals and Healing at the Borders of Death (Lantern Books); CANINES IN THE CLASSROOM, Raising Humane Children through Interactions with Animals;(Lantern Books) DO DOGS HAVE BELLY BUTTONS? 100 Questions and Answers about Dogs(Adams Media); THE SIMPLE LITTLE VEGAN SLOW COOKER and THE SIMPLE LITTLE VEGAN DOG BOOK(Book Publishers, Inc.) and ON DOGS AND DYING (Purdue University Press). She is also an essayist and has been published in the vegetarian essay book “Voices from the Garden.” She is a freelance writer/editor and along with her Certified Therapy Dogs, a Humane Educator and R.E.A.D tutor. Michelle is a past blogger for and a writer for several online publications including eHow, Livestrong, Rachel Ray, The Daily Puppy, USA Today, Cracked and others. She has two Certified Delta Society Therapy Dogs: Murphy, a Golden Retriever, and Tabitha, a Standard Poodle; and two cats. All are rescued animals. Michelle lives in South Florida with her husband, John, an attorney, and is the proud grandmother of three lovely children, Austin, Alexander and Adrienne.

Popular posts

  1. And The Moon is the Only Light We See.... (19 votes)
  2. What's in a Hot Dog? (18 votes)
  3. What's a No-Kill Shelter? (16 votes)
View all posts

Leave a Comment

  1. Virtually Homemade
    Virtually Homemade
    Thank you for all that information and all the work you do on behalf of animals. My kids and I had a beta fish as well and we enjoyed him like you. However, I often wondered about the conditions they were kept in at Petco. Now I know, pretty sad. I think I'll stick with my humane society doggie! Voted! Check out my watermelon basil soda recipe :)
    Log in to reply.
  2. SnakeWitch
    Great article! Indeed, pet suppliers may also be the ones lying. You used the example of puppy mills for that. I mean, they lie about anything these days just for a few bucks - including our food. GMOs cause cancer and the companies that genetically modify food know it. The reason why they insist so much about lying is that they spent millions on research and won't accept to lose it all. Sad, really. However, I will still boycott pet stores because if we purchase from them, we are giving them a 'yes' vote involuntarily. I applaud your willingness to get these fish out of their harmful environment, but we have to remember that one life isn't worth encouraging an unhealthy company. I'm not criticising your purchase, but would like to give you my opinion so you can think about whether you still want to shop at pet stores. I voted! I have an article on Permaculture. Would you like to check it out - and vote please!
    Log in to reply.
  3. Carolyn
    Vote # 5 Michelle!
    Log in to reply.
  4. Carolyn
    Congrats for making Top Posts!
    Log in to reply.
  5. LibbyTreats
    Great article. It's sad, I saw these beautiful fish for sale in those tiny cups at my local dollar store! Thankfully that store is closed now.
    Log in to reply.
    1. DogWriter
      At your dollar store??!!! That's outrageous. I saw a shelf for them at Wal Mart but there were no fish on the shelf. Where do you live? We need to get those fish out of the dollar store!!! Are they actually selling them for $1?
      Log in to reply.
      1. LibbyTreats
        I live in the DC area. No, they weren't $1, but I think $3.98. That dollar store is now closed and I haven't been in any others nearby. It was a Dollar Power store. Not sure if it is a chain, but this one was independently operated.
        Log in to reply.
  6. vig
    Log in to reply.


Connect with The Flaming Vegan

Sign Up to Vote!

10 second sign-up with Facebook or Google

Already a member? Log in to vote.