The Flaming Vegan

A Vegan and Vegetarian Blogging Extravaganza

Challenging Assumptions About Eggs: Are Free Range Really Any Better?
Facebook Tweet Google+ Pinterest Email More Sharing Options

Challenging Assumptions About Eggs: Are Free Range Really Any Better?

Recent research at Bristol University in the UK has called into question just how much better for chickens free range farming is, and acts as more evidence for the animal rights benefits of veganism.

Comparing chickens after they've hatched

The study looked at the condition of chickens kept in a range of different farming styles, including battery cages, enriched cages, barn systems and free-range.

The findings in relation to battery cages will surprise no-one. These barbaric cells have long been recognised as incredibly harmful to chickens, and were banned in Europe in 2012.

But the findings on free range farms were more surprising. Often held up as the ethical way to farm chickens, some of these farms had chickens in worse conditions than those kept in non-battery cages. Smaller free range systems in particular showed higher levels of stress, pecking and deaths among the chickens.

A problem of control

One of the report's authors concluded that what is needed is improved management of the free range farm system, so that it enforces the sort of welfare consumers expect when they see the words 'free range'. But is this really enough? Short of a cripplingly costly inspection regime, it would be near impossible to properly supervise the conditions in all chicken farms. Top-down control is impractical, and bottom-up economic factors drive farmers to cram more birds into a small space, even if it is theoretically free range.

Time to bring this to an end?

Regardless, it is clear that no farm provides the conditions chickens really seek. As long as they are kept in this way they will be exposed to stress, discomfort and harm.

How much longer can anyone say that is worth it for the sake of an egg?

 

Image by SMcGarnigle via Flickr creative commons

Healthy Snacks Delivered Monthly

Leave a Comment

  1. beachgurl
    What is a commercial free range farm like? Maybe I don't want to know. The farmers that sell eggs around here seem to take care of them like pets. Though not all keep them around when they stop laying eggs, (at least two do) . That untimely end also makes you question whether it's worth it for the sake of an egg. Always like your blogs.
    Log in to reply.
    1. Andrew Knighton
      Andrew Knighton
      Thanks - glad you're enjoying my posts. I don't have first hand experience of what any of these places are like, and like you, I suspect that I don't really want to know. But it's nice to know that at least some farmers do better by their birds.
      Log in to reply.
      1. beachgurl
        I'm rural, and these are really small farmers that sell only from their farms. One lady has an assortment of birds and some of them roost outside her bedroom window. Someone tried to break into her house in the middle of the night and the birds started squawking. They were able to chase the robber away. She loves her birds and treats them like queens. Keep writing! You have a gift!
        Log in to reply.
        1. Andrew Knighton
          Andrew Knighton
          I love the idea of guard chickens. And thanks very much for your positive comments!
          Log in to reply.

Explore

Connect with The Flaming Vegan

Sign Up to Vote!

10 second sign-up with Facebook or Google

Already a member? Log in to vote.